Why bravery means business
What can brands learn from the likes of Harry Styles and Bad Bunny? Carmen Rodriguez, Global Chief Growth Officer and Partner at GUT notes their success represents a cultural shift away from safe mass appeal towards bold, participatory identity building.
If you scroll through most industry announcements today, whether it be fashion, tech or entertainment, it’s striking how quickly everything starts to blur together. The same aesthetics, tone of voice and polished brand behaviour designed to appeal to the masses and offend… nobody.
For years brands have been told that consistency and brand appeal are safe routes to success, that avoiding sharp edges will win out in the long run. But today's cultural landscape is so fragmented and crowded with content, creators and conversations, that brands are competing with culture itself rather than simply with each other.
When people feel they are participating in a culture rather than consuming a product, spending becomes part of the experience.
In that environment, what makes brands disappear is the lack of a defined point of view. Audiences are gravitating towards brands that feel distinctive and culturally relevant.
The shift is visible far beyond brands. In music, some of today’s biggest stars have succeeded not by appealing to everyone, but by creating worlds that people actively want to belong to.
Harry Styles has shown how individuality and self-expression can evolve into something much bigger than the artists themselves. His concerts have become rituals of participation, where feather boas, sequins and heart-shaped sunglasses are as much a part of the experience as the music itself. Fans are stepping into a cultural world built around flamboyance, playfulness and self-expression.
Credits
View on- Agency Edelman/Chicago
Explore full credits, grab hi-res stills and more on shots Vault
Credits
powered by- Agency Edelman/Chicago
Above: Dove has spent two decades pushing for a wider definition of female beauty. It’s a message that has endured as well as the refreshingly mature models featured in this 2024 spot.
It's little surprise that attendees at Styles’s UK tour dates are expected to outspend those at Taylor Swift or Oasis concerts. When people feel they are participating in a culture rather than consuming a product, spending becomes part of the experience.
cultural relevance doesn't come from watering down your identity to reach more people.
But perhaps the strongest example of cultural bravery comes from Bad Bunny. Rather than adapting himself for the mainstream, he has consistently made the mainstream adapt to him. From bringing Puerto Rican culture to a global audience to debunking long-established industry norms, he has built his success by doubling down on authenticity rather than compromise. His recent Super Bowl halftime performance, delivered entirely in Spanish, was a powerful statement that cultural relevance doesn't come from watering down your identity to reach more people, but in expressing it genuinely with enough conviction that others want to join in.
Having a point of view doesn't necessarily mean chasing the latest trend or being deliberately provocative.
Both artists demonstrate the same principle. Modern audiences buy into identities, communities and cultural moments that reflect how they want to feel. The most culturally relevant brands understand that people increasingly value participation over passive consumption and personality over polish. In a crowded culture, what makes something resonate is the confidence to stand for something distinctive.
You can see this in the rise of brands leaning harder into distinct identities rather than mass-market neutrality. But having a point of view doesn't necessarily mean chasing the latest trend or being deliberately provocative. Sometimes, it means staying committed to the same belief for decades.
Dove is perhaps one of the clearest examples of this. For more than 20 years, its Real Beauty platform has challenged beauty standards and championed a broader representation of women. Long before purpose became fashionable, Dove had established a clear perspective and stuck with it. While campaigns and channels have evolved, their underlying core values have remained consistent, proving that bravery is about having the confidence to stand for something over time.
Credits
powered byAbove: Bad Bunny sent a strong , impactful and timely message to Super Bowl fans this year about the relevance of Latino culture in the US.
At the other end of the spectrum is Nothing, the tech company that managed to make smartphones culturally interesting again with tongue-in-cheek marketing and activations, amplified further through collaborations that feel unexpected but culturally fluent - most recently announcing Charli XCX becoming both an investor and creative partner. The common thread across all of these is a clear and distinctive point of view. A willingness to create emotional reactions rather than dilute them away.
Too many campaigns today are refined to the point where nothing surprising survives. Visual identities begin to merge together and tone of voice becomes interchangeable.
The irony is that audiences - who want, more than ever, to participate rather than simply consume – are sensitive to this kind of safety. Particularly younger audiences, who have grown up online surrounded by endless content and can immediately sense when a brand is over-engineered or trying too hard to appeal to everyone at once.
In a landscape increasingly defined by sameness, blending in may be the biggest risk of all.
Therefore conviction becomes a differentiator. The brands willing to risk being disliked by some people in order to be deeply loved by others will ultimately stand the test of time.
That doesn’t mean shock value for the sake of it, but it does mean having the confidence and bravery to commit to a personality, a perspective and a cultural identity rather than endlessly smoothing off all the edges. In a landscape increasingly defined by sameness, blending in may be the biggest risk of all.
Bravery can be as simple as taking a step back and reconnecting with your brand's roots, or as transformative as redefining your positioning, refreshing your identity, or challenging established behaviours.
Brave brands outperform those that play it safe. Not because they are louder or more provocative, but because they give people something distinctive to engage with and remember.
